Should diplomats still have immunity
The system has long proved controversial not least since PC Yvonne Fletcher was shot dead outside the Libyan Embassy in 1984 and is once again under the spotlight thanks to an unusual battle fought in London’s courts.
Saudi businessman Sheikh Walid Juffali launched a diplomatic immunity defence after his ex wife, former Pirelli model Christina Estrada, made a claim on his estimated 4bn fortune. The court heard they separated in 2013.
canada goose black friday sale In a move that had led to raised eyebrows in the press, Juffali was appointed in 2014 by the Caribbean island of Saint Lucia as its permanent representative to the International Maritime Organisation (IMO), which canada goose deals has its secretariat in London. canada goose black friday sale
canada goose coats In February, Mr Justice Hayden ruled at the High Court this diplomatic status was “an entirely artificial construct” as Juffali had “no pre existing connection to St Lucia” and there was no evidence that he had “any knowledge or experience of maritime matters”. canada goose coats
Article 29, The Vienna Convention on Diplomatic Relations (1961)
canadian goose jacket “The person of a diplomatic agent shall be inviolable. He shall not be liable to any form of arrest or detention. Canada Goose sale The receiving State shall treat him with due respect and shall take all appropriate steps to prevent any attack on his person, freedom or dignity.”Read the full document here canadian goose jacket
Last week, the Court of Appeal said the judge had been wrong to rule Juffali was not “entitled in principle to immunity”. However, Canada Goose Outlet it dismissed the appeal on the basis that his diplomatic status was irrelevant as Juffali was a permanent British resident and thus liable to civil action, as permanent residents serving as diplomats are immune only from prosecution for official acts.
uk canada goose outlet After the verdict, a spokesman for Juffali said he was “committed to maintaining his diplomatic cheap Canada Goose duties” and noted that St Lucia’s prime minister had testified to the Canada Goose Parka “exemplary manner” in which Juffali had carried out his role. However, he was “dismayed” by the court’s decision that he was a UK permanent resident. uk canada goose outlet
canada goose clearance sale In a statement, the government of St Lucia said it “has, and will always, follow full due process” in appointing canada goose coats on sale diplomats and Juffali’s case was no different. The IMO declined to comment. canada goose clearance sale
Canada Goose Coats On Sale The convention of diplomatic immunity intended to prevent embassy staff being harassed when operating in hostile countries is a long standing cornerstone of international relations that dates back centuries prior to being enshrined in the Vienna Convention. Canada Goose Coats On Sale
However, the Juffali case is not the first time diplomatic immunity which covers around 25,000 people in the UK, including families of some diplomats as well as the officials themselves has attracted scrutiny.
Canada Goose sale In 2010 the then Foreign Secretary William Hague released details of 18 crimes including sexual assault, human trafficking, threats to kill and drink driving of which diplomats in the UK had been accused during 2010. Canada Goose sale
Canada Goose online In buy canada goose jacket December it was reported that embassy workers had run up 95m of unpaid congestion charges in London because they argue it is a tax, not a charge for service, and thus exempt under the Vienna Convention. Canada Goose online
It was ruled in February that because of his diplomatic status, Sheikh Hamad Bin Jassim Bin Jaber Al Thani one of the world’s richest men buy canada goose jacket cheap and the former prime minister of Qatar could not be sued in the UK over claims a British Qatari dual national canada goose store was falsely imprisoned. Sheikh Hamad and the state of Qatar have denied any wrongdoing, with lawyers for the billionaire saying the man in question had been treated “in the manner that accorded fully with Qatari and international law”.
canada goose Diplomatic immunity versus local law canada goose
In 2013, Indian deputy consul general Devyani Khobragade (pictured) was arrested in New York on suspicion of visa fraud her role as a consul did not provide diplomatic immunity canadian goose jacket but the Indian government moved her to a position at the UN, where she would be covered by immunity. Khobragade denied any wrongdoing
canada goose coats on sale Qatari Sheikh Khalid Hamad Al Thani left the US abruptly after video footage emerged showing his Ferrari drag racing through Beverley Hills; whether or not he had diplomatic immunity was disputed, and it was never established who was driving anyway canada goose coats on sale
Russian diplomat Dmitry Borodin was arrested in the Netherlands and detained for three hours by police, despite www.cg-jacketsale.ca his diplomatic immunity; local media reported that police were called over alleged mistreatment of children and that Borodin was drunk when arrested. The Russian foreign ministry and Borodin vigorously denied the allegations
canada goose clearance In 1997 Georgian diplomat Gueorgui Makharadze had his diplomatic immunity waived by his government after he caused a five car pile up in Washington DC resulting in the death of a teenage girl canada goose clearance
canada goose uk black friday Cases like these have led to calls for the whole system to be overhauled. Human rights barrister Geoffrey Robertson QC says the Vienna canada goose outlet Convention made sense in the days of the Cold War when embassy staff working in hostile nations were at risk of being framed or caught in honeytraps but has passed its sell by date. canada goose uk black friday
cheap canada goose uk “What it does is put diplomats above the law,” he says. “It’s a breach of Magna Carta. cheap canada goose uk
“I think the Vienna Convention needs redrafting to limit diplomatic immunity. I don’t think diplomatic immunity should extend to any civil case. It canada goose clearance should only extend to criminal canada goose clearance sale cases in limited circumstances.”
He also argues that the definition of “diplomat” is too wide encompassing not just ambassadors representing their nation in overseas embassies, but also at specialised agencies of the United Nations and other international bodies.
cheap Canada Goose And while it’s unusual for states to nominate foreign nationals as diplomats, as in the case of canada goose coats Juffali, there are concerns that the system could potentially be exploited by those trying to evade the court process. cheap Canada Goose
buy canada goose jacket “There are a number of countries around the world where you can effectively buy citizenship,” says solicitor Mark Stephens, a former president of the Commonwealth Lawyers Association. There’s a danger this could be taken a step further for the right price, he believes. “If you are a Mr Big behind a multi million pound fraud it behoves you to get a diplomatic passport so Canada Goose Jackets you have diplomatic immunity.” buy canada goose jacket
In practice, however, ambassadorial status does not put you entirely outside the boundaries of the Canada Goose online law unlike Joss Ackland’s drug smuggling South African consul general in that definitive big screen portrayal of diplomatic statecraft, Lethal Weapon 2, who waves his diplomatic passport while committing nefarious deeds.
